How people’s movements have influenced research priorities in India
Abstract
**Context**: The systematization of social science research in India under the state began in the 1950s and 1960s, although high-quality noteworthy research had been conducted by independent scholars for many years. The earliest institutions were those set up by central ministries essentially with the objective of conducting research in areas relevant to the county's development. The Planning Commission (now disbanded) provided the first impetus to initiating research relevant to policy making. It produced a wealth of policy-relevant research, mostly in the field of economics and management, and essentially focused on deriving policy recommendations and rarely touched on larger issues or conceptual and methodological questions. A notable exception is the large body of globally recognized poverty studies over the decades.
The Indian Council of Social Science Research (ICSSR) was set up almost 20 years after independence. Even by 2007~of a total of 417~research institutions listed by ICSSR, there were no university, ICSSR or government-funded research institutions specializing in minorities and scheduled castes and tribes, women, health-related subjects, or history. The general perception has been that the quality of research in formal institutions had deteriorated, and that there is a general reluctance to conduct independent research on critical and sensitive issues. Health-services research and health-systems research have been conducted under the Indian Council for Medical Research, the premier body funding medical and health research. But these are a small number and mostly in medical institutions. The ICMR's focus has been on medical research rather than health care in its broad definition.
The indirect fallout of the general neglect of such research in government-funded institutions, especially in some areas, has been a proliferation of privately funded social sciences research organizations. There has been no systematic assessment of the research undertaken by NGOs and independent institutions. This research is most often glibly regarded as being of poor quality, biased by the funder's requirements, or not sufficiently rigorous. And yet it is these institutions where research has focused on issues relevant to vulnerable groups and sensitive social issues. Two major research areas that have developed in this sector are health and women's issues.
\textbf{People's movements and research production} --- Among the earliest movements that had an impact on law, governance, and research was in Kerala on the threat to fisherfolk livelihood due to increased use of mechanized trawlers. The movement, which began in the 1970s, later broadened to include impacts of the ocean environment and fish stocks. It then catalyzed a wide-ranging research program, in universities and among independent social scientists, on the impact of trawling, purse seining, and ocean pollution and on the economic and social organization of fisheries.
In parallel, over the years young professionals, who were disenchanted with their institutional settings and their lack of engagement with the people and their needs, have established outposts outside academia to conduct socially relevant research. This is perhaps the beginning of the emergence of the concept of "lokvidya" or people's knowledge that reinforces local knowledge traditions in technology, science, arts and crafts, and society and community. Less recognized is the fact that there has been considerable thought given to the methodological, philosophical, and epistemological issues within these movements. Unfortunately, in the Indian context, these discussions have mostly remained within closed circles. They have neither as yet enhanced the knowledge base nor informed pedagogy in these fields.
The Narmada Bachao Andolan, a protest movement against the building of a series of large and small dams on the River Narmada, lead to better assessment of the needs of the displaced, dismantled the well accepted techno-economic basis of building large dams, and exposed the poor scientific understanding of hydrology and seismicity on which the decisions were based. It had a major impact on the development decisions of the Indian government, prompted the World Bank to reform how it approved grants, and because some issues were challenged in court, it produced considerable legal literature.
Within the health sector, the Medico Friend Circle (MFC) emerged in the 1970s to address the abysmal Medicare available in villages. These young medical professionals brought into focus several problems in the delivery of rural health care, in particular medicines and the unethical practices of the pharmaceutical industry. The MFC critically reviewed pharmaceutical literature, and encouraged ideological debates across the political divide on issues of medical care. MFC made many contributions to path-breaking research, and even more importantly, it consistently and systematically established the connection between people's health and their social and economic conditions. In 2000, the health movement became more formalized as Jan Swasthya Abhiyan, which campaigned for health for all now, and viewed health as a fundamental right. It has taken up several public issues in healthcare from a rights perspective and made use of research studies from various institutions.
The women's movement has encouraged an interdisciplinary approach to the study of gender issues. Gender studies centres are mandated within all public universities, and in 1983, the Indian Association of Women's Studies was established by scholars working in universities and colleges. The Indian women's movement is one area where there has been a symbiosis of movement-led research and research emerging through formal scholarship.~
Alternative knowledge streams generated by movements and their institutions have: posed a challenge to the state and markets; produced evidence to challenge existing paradigms of development; informed policy change; filled gaps in knowledge to counter the deliberate silences of the establishment; served to critique science and society connections and thereby helped to ground science in social policy; and contributed to the formation of alternative perspectives.
Lire le chapitre

PDF de 6 pages, tel qu’imprimé dans l’ouvrage, pages 49 à 54. En libre accès.
Pas encore de consultation enregistrée.